Insurance brokers have urged the government to reconsider IRDAI’s proposed commission caps, warning that the changes could affect jobs, distribution and policyholder access.
Insurance brokers have stepped up their opposition to the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India’s (IRDAI) proposed commission reforms, warning that tighter limits could affect jobs, distribution networks and the wider insurance market. The Insurance Brokers Association of India (IBAI) has written to the Prime Minister and Finance Minister seeking intervention.
IRDAI proposed the changes through its “Recalibrating Economics of Insurance Distribution” discussion paper in September. The regulator wants commissions to reflect product complexity, distribution channels and the effort required to sell and service policies. Stakeholders can submit feedback until October 25.
IRDAI Proposes Tighter Commission Limits
The proposed IRDAI commission caps cover banks, brokers and agents across several insurance products. Mandatory covers such as third-party motor insurance could attract little or no commission.
For banks and lenders that distribute insurance alongside loans, proposed commissions could range between 2% and 5%, depending on the product. IRDAI also wants to prohibit compulsory insurance bundling with credit.
For health insurance, the proposal sets distributor commission limits of 15% to 20% at purchase, while renewals and portability could carry lower limits of 5% to 10%. Life insurance commissions would also vary according to policy tenure and distribution channel.
The regulator aims to reduce distribution costs and improve affordability for insurance policyholders. However, brokers argue that lower commissions will not automatically translate into lower premiums unless insurers pass the savings to customers.
Brokers Warn of Jobs and Distribution Risks
IBAI estimates that the proposed IRDAI commission caps could put at least one million livelihoods at risk over five years. The estimate excludes salaried employees working directly for insurers. The association also fears that tighter limits could reduce the reach of insurance distribution, particularly in smaller markets.
Brokers have also warned that strict commission limits could encourage alternative payment arrangements. IBAI has raised concerns that insurers could classify excess distributor payments as marketing fees, potentially creating new compliance challenges and reviving unethical practices.
The association wants IRDAI to conduct a detailed impact assessment covering insurance policyholders, employment, public sector insurers and foreign investment before introducing hard commission caps. It has also asked the government to retain the existing framework until its scheduled 2028 review.
The proposals remain under consultation, so the final IRDAI commission rules may differ from the current framework. The regulator will consider stakeholder feedback before deciding on the next steps.
Life Insurance Overview: Understand the basics of life insurance and why adequate protection matters for individuals and families.
Also Read: Swiss Re, Bajaj General Join Hands on Commercial Insurance
Disclaimer: This MyRupia article provides information based on publicly available government, regulatory and industry sources. It does not constitute investment, financial, tax, insurance or legal advice. Information, examples, market data and expert views may change over time and do not represent a recommendation to buy, sell, invest in or surrender any financial product. Readers should consider their individual circumstances and consult a qualified financial professional before making financial decisions.
