India’s proposed insurance distribution reforms have triggered resistance from brokers and automobile dealers, who warn that commission caps could threaten jobs and disrupt motor insurance sales. IRDAI says the changes aim to curb mis-selling, reduce distribution costs and improve value for policyholders.
India’s proposed insurance distribution overhaul has drawn strong opposition from insurance brokers and automobile dealers, who warn that commission caps could threaten jobs, reduce distributor earnings and disrupt established sales channels. The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) says the reforms aim to curb mis-selling and lower costs for policyholders.
The Insurance Brokers Association of India (IBAI), which represents more than 770 brokers, has written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the finance minister seeking intervention. In letters dated October 2, the association warned that the proposals could put at least one million livelihoods at risk over five years.
Brokers seek review of commission caps
IRDAI released its consultation paper, Recalibrating Economics of Insurance Distribution, on September 23. The proposals would set commission limits across insurance products and distribution channels, alongside tighter limits on insurers’ overall management expenses.
The regulator wants to link commissions to product complexity and the effort required to sell a policy. It also aims to reduce incentives that encourage distributors to recommend unsuitable products or bundle insurance with loans without adequate customer choice.
IBAI argues that lower commissions will not automatically reduce premiums or benefit customers. The association estimates that the proposed framework could cut broker revenues by nearly 70%. It has requested an independent impact assessment and an extension of the consultation deadline from October 25 to late December.
The association also warns that insurers could disguise payments above the proposed limits as marketing fees. It wants the government to retain the current commission framework until its scheduled review in 2028.
Auto dealers oppose motor insurance limits
Automobile dealers have raised separate concerns about the proposed motor insurance commission structure. The Federation of Automobile Dealers Associations (FADA), which represents more than 15,000 dealers, is gathering industry feedback ahead of the consultation deadline.
Under the proposal, distributors would receive no commission on third-party motor insurance for new vehicles and a maximum of 5% on own-damage cover. The framework would also limit payouts on renewals.
FADA argues that dealers do more than sell a policy. They help customers choose cover, coordinate documentation and provide support throughout the insurance process. Its representatives question whether a 5% commission would adequately cover these services.
However, IRDAI’s proposed changes could give vehicle buyers greater freedom to compare insurance products instead of relying on dealer-linked options. The regulator also wants to reduce distribution costs in a market where commissions have risen sharply.
Policyholder benefits remain central
The debate highlights a key challenge for India’s insurance sector: balancing affordable insurance with a sustainable distribution network. IRDAI must consider the concerns of brokers and dealers while ensuring that commission structures do not encourage mis-selling or restrict customer choice.
The regulator will review stakeholder feedback before finalising the framework. Until then, the proposed commission caps remain under consultation, and their final design and implementation timeline may change.
Life Insurance Overview: Understand the basics of life insurance and why adequate protection matters for individuals and families.
Also Read: AI Chatbots Change How Indians Shop Car Insurance
Disclaimer: This MyRupia article provides information based on publicly available government, regulatory and industry sources. It does not constitute investment, financial, tax, insurance or legal advice. Information, examples, market data and expert views may change over time and do not represent a recommendation to buy, sell, invest in or surrender any financial product. Readers should consider their individual circumstances and consult a qualified financial professional before making financial decisions.
