Endowment Insurance Plans: What Brochures Promise vs Actual Returns
Endowment insurance plans are among the most sold and often, most misunderstood financial products in India. They are pitched as a “safe, guaranteed” product that provides life cover and returns your money with “bonuses” at the end of a defined term. What are the facts?
Avg Annualised Returns
New IRDAI Surrender Rules
Tax-Free Premium Cap
Understanding the actual economics of an endowment plan can help you make an informed decision before committing to a product for 15-25 years. This guide will explain how endowment plans operate, how returns are computed, what bonuses actually imply, how surrender values operate, and whether or not these plans are appropriate for long-term financial objectives.
What is an Endowment Plan?
A standard life insurance product that unifies two separate elements under a single policy is an endowment plan.
- Life Insurance Coverage: The nominee gets the amount promised if the policyholder passes away within the policy’s term.
- Savings Component: The policyholder receives the cash promised plus accrued bonuses if they live out the period.
Since a percentage goes toward the savings component, premiums are greater than those for term insurance. The insurer declares yearly bonuses from the excess that results from the conservative management of these pooled funds, which are mostly invested in government securities and debt instruments.
There are two types of endowment plans: “participating” and “non-participating” policies. Through bonuses, participating plans receive a portion of the insurer’s profits. Non-participating plans offer a fixed, predetermined payout with no bonus element.
How Does an Endowment Plan Work?
Every premium you pay is divided into multiple components by the insurer.
| Premium Component | What It Covers |
|---|---|
| Mortality charge | Cost of providing the life cover. Increases with the policyholder’s age. |
| Policy administration charges | Insurer’s operational costs, including agent commissions and paperwork. |
| Savings / investment component | The balance amount is invested in government bonds and approved debt instruments. |
| GST on premium | 18% on mortality charges and policy administration fees. |
Comprehending Endowment Plan Bonuses
In participating endowment plans, bonuses play an important part in the maturity value. There are several kinds, and it’s critical to comprehend what each entails.
Bonus for Simple Reversion (SRB)
Declared yearly as a set sum per ₹1,000 of the assured amount. For instance, ₹45,000 is added for that year if the bonus rate is ₹45 per ₹1,000 on a total assured of ₹10 lakh. Crucially, this addition is straightforward (non-compounding).
Final Additional Bonus (FAB)
A one-time bonus payable at maturity or death if the policy has run for a minimum number of years. It is not guaranteed and depends on the insurer’s financials.
Guaranteed Additions
Some newer plans offer a fixed percentage added to the sum assured each year in place of a declared bonus. These are fixed at policy inception and do not fluctuate.
The Return Question: What an Endowment Plan Actually Earns
The real return on the premiums paid is the main concern with endowment programmes.
The real return from an endowment plan is frequently little or even negative in terms of purchasing power after accounting for inflation (India’s retail inflation has averaged between five and six per cent over the past ten years).
An Example Scenario
Consider a 30-year-old buying an endowment plan with a 20-year term and an annual premium of ₹50,000. ₹10 lakh is the total premium outflow.
| Option | Total Invested | Approx. Maturity Value | Approx. Annualised Return |
|---|---|---|---|
| Endowment plan (traditional) | ₹10 lakh | ₹13-14 lakh | 4-5% p.a. |
| Public Provident Fund (PPF) | ₹10 lakh | ₹21-22 lakh | 7.1% p.a. (tax-free) |
| Fixed deposit | ₹10 lakh | ₹18-20 lakh | 6.5-7% p.a. |
| Balanced mutual fund (illustrative) | ₹10 lakh | ₹28-30 lakh | 10% p.a. (not guaranteed) |
Why are Endowment Plan Returns Lower Than Comparable Options?
Several structural reasons contribute to the lower return profile of endowment plans.
- Dual-Purpose Premium: Every premium pays for both insurance cover and savings. The mortality charge and administration costs reduce the amount actually invested.
- Conservative Investment Mandate: The majority of policyholder funds must be invested by insurers in authorised bonds and government securities. In contrast to stocks, these investments often yield lower long-term returns.
- Non-Compounding Bonuses: Simple Reversionary Bonuses do not compound; instead, they accumulate as a flat annual addition. This severely restricts the mature corpus’s growth during the next 15 to 20 years.
- Embedded Costs: The pricing includes insurer profit margins, agent commissions, and administrative costs, all of which lower the policyholder’s effective return.
“Guaranteed Returns”: What This Phrase Actually Means
The word “guaranteed” appears prominently in endowment plan marketing. But it’s crucial to know exactly what is and isn’t guaranteed.
What Is Guaranteed vs What Is Not
Guaranteed:
- The sum assured payable on death or maturity.
- Guaranteed surrender value (as per IRDAI norms).
Not Guaranteed:
- Bonuses (Simple Reversionary, Final Additional). These are declared at the insurer’s discretion each year.
- The projected maturity illustration shown at the time of sale. These are projections based on assumed bonus rates, not commitments.
When an agent or brochure shows you a maturity amount, it is a projection, not a promise. If bonus rates are reduced over the policy’s life (which has happened historically as interest rates declined), the actual maturity value will be lower than projected.
What Happens If You Exit an Endowment Plan Early?
Endowment plans are long-term commitments. Exiting early, known as surrendering the policy, comes at a cost.
How Surrender Value is Calculated
The surrender value is determined by the insurer using either the Special Surrender Value (SSV) or the Guaranteed Surrender Value (GSV).
- GSV: Determined by adding a percentage of vested bonuses to the total premiums paid, excluding first-year premiums in earlier policies. The GSV factors are defined in the policy document.
- SSV: A higher figure determined by the insurer using the policy’s paid-up value and current market conditions. Higher SSVs are needed under IRDAI regulations starting in October 2024, thereby lowering the cost of early retirement.
Updated IRDAI Surrender Norms (Effective October 2024)
With effect from October 1, 2024, IRDAI modified its surrender value rules in an effort to improve policyholder returns. Major changes consist of:
- Previously, no value was payable if surrendered in the first year; however, surrender value is now offered upon payment of just one year’s premium.
- At the time of sale, insurers have to offer policyholders surrender value illustrations.
- All savings-linked life insurance policies require policy loans, allowing policyholders to borrow against the policy instead of surrendering it.
- Policies sold on or after October 1, 2024, are subject to these revised criteria. Existing policies continue under their original terms.
| Year of Surrender | Approx. GSV (% of premiums paid) | What this means |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 (policies sold before Oct 2024) | Nil | No refund on surrender |
| Years 2-3 | 30-35% | You receive less than a third of the premiums paid. |
| Years 4-7 | 50% | You receive approximately half of the premiums paid. |
| Last 2 years of the premium term | Up to 90% | Closer to full premium recovery |
Who Might Consider an Endowment Plan?
Endowment plans may be suitable for:
- Individuals who struggle with long-term savings discipline and need a structured, forced-savings mechanism with life cover built in.
- Those with very low risk tolerance who prioritise capital protection and guaranteed (even if low) returns over market-linked growth.
- Buyers with specific goal-based needs, such as a defined sum available at a specific future date, where the certainty of the amount matters more than maximising returns.
But a term plan typically provides far greater coverage for the exact same or lower price if the purpose is enough life insurance. Based on the individual’s situation, options like PPF, NPS, or mutual funds could offer better risk-adjusted results if the goal is long-term wealth growth.
If You Already Have an Endowment Plan: Your Options
If you have realised that the endowment plan you hold may not align with your financial goals, you have several practical options.
Step 1: Determine Your Real IRR
Determine the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) using your premium amount, the number of years left, and the estimated maturity value from your policy paperwork. There are a number of free internet calculators available. This value informs you of the true annualised return you are getting.
Step 2: Evaluate Alternatives
Examine the IRR in relation to the anticipated long-term returns from a balanced portfolio, the FD rates provided by top banks, and the current PPF rates (7.1% p.a. as of FY 2025-2026).
Step 3: Think About Paying for the Policy
If the plan is underperforming but surrendering would result in a heavy loss, one option is to make the policy “paid-up.” You stop paying future premiums. The sum assured is reduced proportionately. Accumulated bonuses remain attached. The policy continues until maturity with no further outflow.
Step 4: Consider Surrender After the Heavy-Penalty Window
If the policy is in its early years and the surrender value is low, it may be worth waiting until the penalty reduces (typically years 5-7 under older policies) before reviewing whether to exit.
Step 5: Separate Insurance From Investment Going Forward
Regardless of the decision on the existing policy, life insurance cover is best addressed through a term plan, and financial goals are best addressed through appropriate investment products suited to your risk profile and time horizon.
Need Help Auditing Your Policy's Real Yield?
Not sure which policy suits your needs the most? Use our Savings Decoder and find the best to align with your goals, timeline, and risk preferences.
Need personalised guidance? Talk to an Expert!
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between an endowment plan and a term plan?
A term plan provides pure life insurance coverage and pays the sum assured only if the policyholder dies during the policy term. Endowment plans combine insurance with savings, offering maturity benefits if the policyholder survives. Because of this savings component, endowment plans usually provide lower life cover and lower returns for the same premium.
Are endowment plan maturity proceeds tax-free?
Maturity proceeds may qualify for tax exemption under Section 10(10D), subject to applicable conditions. For policies issued after 1 April 2023, the exemption generally applies only if the annual premium does not exceed ₹5 lakh. If premiums exceed this limit, the maturity amount may become taxable.
What are the new IRDAI surrender norms effective October 2024?
Effective 1 October 2024, revised IRDAI norms require insurers to provide surrender value after just one year’s premium payment. The rules also increase Special Surrender Values and require clearer surrender value illustrations at the point of sale. These norms apply only to policies issued on or after 1 October 2024.
Can I partially withdraw from an endowment plan?
Traditional endowment plans generally do not allow partial withdrawals. Policyholders usually either continue paying premiums, convert the policy into paid-up status, or surrender it for the surrender value.
What is a paid-up policy, and is it a good option?
A paid-up policy is one where the policyholder stops paying future premiums, but the policy continues with a reduced sum assured. Accumulated bonuses usually remain attached, and the reduced payout is received at maturity.
Disclaimer: Returns and values mentioned in this article are illustrative and based on typical traditional endowment plan characteristics. Actual returns vary by insurer, product, policy term, and declared bonus rates. Tax treatment is based on current provisions of the Income Tax Act and may change. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice.
ON THIS PAGE
- What is an Endowment Plan?
- How Does an Endowment Plan Work?
- Comprehending Endowment Plan Bonuses
- The Return Question: What an Endowment Plan Actually Earns
- Why are Endowment Plan Returns Lower Than Comparable Options?
- “Guaranteed Returns”: What This Phrase Actually Means
- What Happens If You Exit an Endowment Plan Early?
- Who Might Consider an Endowment Plan?
- If You Already Have an Endowment Plan: Your Options
- FAQs
Not sure what you need?
Speak with an expert who charges for advice — not for selling a policy.